Mirrors Are, For Human Beings, Becoming Scary …

I RobotWhile you are distracted making a living in a politically mismanaged economy and journalists are distracted by one bunch of Arabs with guns called ISIS, some sober scientists are off in a lab, making mischief. They are studying the human brain.

Were many aware of what they are doing, it seems likely that there would be demonstrations or even mobs attacking it. Anyone caught wearing a lab coat might be hung from the nearest lamppost. But no one is looking. What none sees, might well change our entire society into something hard to recognize.

When MRI and PET scanning became available, human brain researchers saw a chance to research that organ. One of them, a Brit named Dr. Adrian Raine, saw brain scans as a n opportunity to discover how our brains work. He wondered whether criminality emanated from the brain, but British science was convinced that crimiality was a social response based upon poverty and poor upbringing, Dr. Raine’s biological issue was unwelcome. He emigrated to the U.S. and began scanning the brains of imprisoned criminals. And he found differences from the brains of his control groups of ‘normal’ citizens.

Today, others have joined Dr. Raine researching human criminality in the brain, though most professionals are still cautious about diagnosing criminality from brain scans. Even more caution arises as this type of evidence begins to be introduced into criminal trials in courts. That strikes us as appropriate, considering what is at stake.

But one thing stands: There is a physical difference between the brain of the psychopathic criminal and normal folk. The difference is visible in scans. And those seem to be facts. That is clouded though, as some with ‘criminal’ brain scans avoid criminal behavior and some convicted criminals lack the telltale brain markers. But most fit the picture, in each case. If these hard, scientific facts cannot indefinitely be ignored, there will be consequences.

Some of the likely issues that occur to us include:

Will a government that is presently reducing the availability of the most expensive medical treatments to the most aged, wish to screen the brains of the unborn in order to eliminate those with a high probability of criminality?

Will those with such brain configurations be left alone by government until they commit a crime?  Will brain scan screening become general at birth or later?

Is our current penal system appropriate for criminals driven by their brain configurations? If not, how is society to protect itself from such behavior?

Those are the easy questions, of course. Just beyond those, lingers the signal issue: Is there really such a thing as Free Will? This has been the short version; if you have read to here, you have the general picture. If you have followed the links, you have a much larger understanding. If you have followed the subject on your own, you know what there is to know. in none of those cases will any ideological tinfoil hat be of help, though such may offer refuge. Such refuges though, are usually illusory …

We will leave off with that last one dangling; we are much too ignorant (and cowardly) to tackle that ourselves at this point. But we are reasonably assured that it will nonetheless remain; it will not go away.

Collapsing, misgoverned economies may prove to be the least of our worries …

Advertisements

About Jack Curtis

Suspicious of government, doubtful of economics, fond of figure skating (but the off-ice part, not so much)
This entry was posted in Culture, Human Nature, Law Enforcement, Politics and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Mirrors Are, For Human Beings, Becoming Scary …

  1. Fasten your seat belts, we may be in for a bumpy ride.

  2. Studies have linked personality types to political parties. The authoritarian or maybe fascist personality is identifiable. Is there such a thing as a “good” fascist? There are good psychopaths. Like Angel, demons with a conscience. Personalities run in families. Children usually “take after” an aunt or uncle or grandparent, rather than their parents. So don’t dream of having a child with the best of you + the best of him/her. You’re more likely to get their sibling or parent. If they are a bastard best not have children. (my family – saints or fascist bastards. Not sure what category I am in. Being rational I remained childless). In a rational society, that knowledge would be helpful. In our present society it will be used to do the greatest harm possible. Any chance of having our leaders scanned for psychopathy or criminal brain before elected?

    • Jack Curtis says:

      🙂 Somehow, it’s easier to foresee government scanning us and/or our progeny than it is to foresee our elite subjecting themselves to what they prescribe for us …
      And that seems to fit whether they be of the right or of the left. (The which I suspect are these days, illusory differences, anyway.)

  3. Michael says:

    Do you think Obama goes through screening before he enters an airplane? The “elite” are immune to our ordinary laws. I am not sure Obama has followed a single one, I bet one of the reasons his university transcripts are sealed is the amount of drugs he was caught using. Where is his arrest record?

    • Jack Curtis says:

      It is said in legal practice that any decent prosecutor ought to be able to get a grand jury to indict a ham sandwich. We’ve now proven that any competent political party can elect one …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s